Should You Refinance Your Mortgage With The Same Lender?

Let’s be honest, refinancing your mortgage sounds like a headache. Paperwork, fees, rate shopping, credit pulls. But when rates drop or your finances improve, the potential savings are hard to ignore.

Here’s the kicker: many homeowners stick with their current lender just to avoid the hassle. But is loyalty worth the cost? Or are you leaving thousands on the table?

• Refinancing with the same lender may offer speed and convenience, but not always the best rates.
• Comparing multiple offers is critical, even from new lenders.
• Credit checks, closing costs, and home equity impact your refinance approval.
• Always request a Loan Estimate to compare APRs and fees.

Speed. Familiarity. Fewer hoops.

There’s a clear appeal to staying with your existing lender:

• Streamlined process: They already have your data, which can speed up approval.
• Less paperwork: No need to re-upload everything (though some re-verification is still required).
• Possibly waived fees: Loyalty perks may include reduced or waived application or appraisal fees.
• Comfort zone: You know their process and how to reach support.

But here’s a pro tip: convenience doesn't always equal savings.

Choosing familiarity over financial advantage could mean:

• Missing lower rates elsewhere
• Paying higher closing costs
• Overlooking better loan structures (shorter terms, lower APRs, etc.)

Even if your current lender offers a decent deal, failing to compare violates the golden rule of refinancing: always get a few quotes.

According to a Freddie Mac survey, borrowers who get at least two quotes save an average of $1,500, and those who get five or more quotes save $3,000+.

Don’t leave that money behind.

1. Check Your Credit Score: Higher scores usually mean lower rates.
2. Request a Loan Estimate: Required by law under TILA/Reg Z. It will outline the APR, interest rate, fees, and terms.
3. Ask About Fees: See what’s negotiable—appraisal, title, origination, etc.
4. Compare With Other Offers: Even one additional quote can change everything.
5. Confirm Timeline: How fast can they close? Is the rate lock long enough?

• You need speed: A quick close is essential.
• They match the best offer, and they’ll lock it immediately.
• Low-to-no fees: You're offered significant cost savings.
• You’re happy with their service, and rate differences are minimal.

Just remember: loyalty isn’t a strategy, it’s a choice. Make sure it’s an informed one.

Even with the same lender, you’ll likely face:

• Origination fees
• Appraisal costs (sometimes waived)
• Title & escrow
• Prepaid taxes/insurance

Heads up: These can total 2–5% of your loan amount.

Use commission-free platforms like realpha to eliminate markups. That’s real savings, no strings attached.

While sticking with your lender might feel “safe,” modern digital platforms are shifting the power to you:

• realpha: A commission-free, buyer-first homebuying platform. Compare offers, skip markups, and get support without sales pressure.
• Be My Neighbor: Licensed and regulated (NMLS #1743790), this platform offers a community-driven refinance experience with a focus on transparency.

Together, they give you control, without sacrificing convenience or compliance.

Yes, generally it’s faster because they already have your file. But speed doesn’t guarantee the best rate or lowest fees.

Yes. Even with the same lender, a hard credit inquiry is standard. You typically have a 45-day window to shop rates without multiple score dings.

Sometimes. Lenders may waive appraisals on low-LTV refinances or automated approvals. Ask upfront.

Under TILA (Reg Z), lenders must provide a Loan Estimate showing APR, fees, and loan terms, so you can compare apples to apples.

Yes, but some may be reduced or rolled into the loan. Always ask.

Refinancing isn’t just about rates, it’s about strategy. Sure, staying with your current lender could save you time. But shopping around, even just a little, can save you thousands.

Ready to refinance smartly?

Use realpha, a commission-free platform that puts your savings first. Or explore personalized guidance through Be My Neighbor (NMLS #1743790), where transparency meets community-driven support.

Don’t refinance blindly. Refinance informed.

• All mortgage transactions are subject to credit approval and underwriting requirements.
• APRs, rates, and loan availability vary by borrower profile and market conditions.
• Always obtain official Loan Estimates from lenders to compare offers.
• NMLS Consumer Access: https://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org
• Be My Neighbor NMLS ID: 1743790
• Realpha is not a mortgage lender but a commission-free technology platform that connects consumers with licensed professionals.

This content complies with applicable federal regulations, including TILA/Reg Z, RESPA, and Regulation N, and does not promote any unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices (UDAAP).